Custom Cakes

Every cake at The Bakery Witch is made to order and designed especially for you. We work with you to create a cake that perfectly suits your celebration — from flavour and fillings to colours, themes and finishing details.

We also offer allergen-friendly options, including eggless, gluten-free and dairy-free cakes, so everyone can enjoy a slice of the celebration.

As each cake is custom made, pricing varies depending on size, flavour and design complexity, and minimum order quantities apply.

 

Pricing

Cake Size	From	Coffee Serves	Dessert Serves
5" x 3 layers	$115	23	15
6"x 3 layers	$125	43	22
6"x 4 layers	$175	57	29
8"x 2 layers	$215	51	26
8" x 3 layers	$315	76	38
8"x 4 layers	$415	101	51

 

Please reach out to us on Whatsapp +61 437916634 for pricing on allergen cakes. 

Available Flavours

Our most requested flavours — and the ones that consistently delight both adults and kids — are Chocolate and Vanilla. These timeless classics pair beautifully with almost any cake design and are always a safe crowd favourite.

For those looking for something a little more unique, we also offer:
Hummingbird Cake, Carrot Cake, Red Velvet Cake, Tiramisu Cake, Biscoff Cake, Caramel Cake, and Lemon Cake.

Frosting

Most of our cakes are finished with our signature condensed milk frosting, known for its smooth texture and balanced sweetness.

The only exceptions are Red Velvet, Carrot Cake, and Hummingbird Cake, which are paired with their traditional cream cheese frosting.

Design Note

For cakes that require a white or light-coloured finish, we generally recommend choosing Chocolate or Vanilla.

While we do offer Biscoff, Caramel, and Lemon, the signature flavour of these cakes comes primarily from the frosting itself. As a result, designs that require coloured frosting may alter the flavour balance and are therefore not recommended for these flavours.

Cupcakes